Fluffernutter Protein Ice Cream

Fluffernutter sandwiches was and still is one of my favorite sandwiches. The combination is the BEST!

Now that I am on my weight loss journey and maintenace from losing 100 pounds I want to enjoy it differently and decided to make it into a delicious protein ice cream.

The ENTIRE pint is only 5 WW, 256 calories and with 36 grams of protein.

Here is what you need:

Ninja CREAMi ice cream maker
Fairlife vanilla protein shake, or shake of choice
Simply Delish sugar free vanilla instant pudding mix
Simply Delish sugar free butterscotch instant pudding mix
Vanilla extract
Marshmallow extract
Salt
PB Fit peanut butter powder
Fluff
Max Mallow marshmallows

This is the AMAZING Ninja CREAMi ice cream maker that makes all the wonderful ice creams that I share. Want to grab one? Click HERE

Fairlife is my absolute favorite protein shake to use for all of my protein ice cream recipes. They always come out super creamy and with ZERO aftertaste.

Here is the marshmallow extract I use. I get it right from Amazon HERE.

This is the ONLY sugar free pudding mixes I use. If you’d like to use Simply Delish click HERE and use code CHEFALLIE for a discount.

Again, if you’d like to use Simply Delish click HERE and use code CHEFALLIE

Fluff is the best and I usually always have it in the house. We have 3 kids so fluffernutters usually happen a lot here.

Max Mallow marshmallows are INSANELY good and the amount you can have for LOW calories and WW points are AWESOME!! Click HERE to order yours.

Here is how to make it:

Place all of the ice cream base ingredients into the Ninja CREAMi pint container
Blend until combine.
Place the lid on top and place into the freezer for 12-24 hours.
Once ready, add to the Ninja CREAMi machine.
Press the “light ice cream” button 1-2 times.
Once creamy, add the peanut butter mixture and the mix-ins.
Press the “Mix-in” button.
Enjoy once done.

Print Recipe